Which Type of Grill Should I Get – Gas or Charcoal?

Charcoal Grill

Learning to become a backyard grill master can be an exciting task. The first step toward this culinary success is deciding which type of grill suits you best. Both options allow a home chef to create incredible meals. Whether you’re drawn to the rich, smoky flavor of charcoal or the convenience of gas, Godby Hearth & Home is Central Indiana’s premier destination for premium grills, offering top-notch options in both categories. We’ve outlined the pros and cons of each option below, creating a BBQ grill decision guide for you to refer to before you make a final decision.

Charcoal Grilling Benefits

Charcoal grills are known for imparting a distinct, smoky flavor to your food. This makes them a favorite when it comes to achieving that authentic barbeque taste. If you’re looking to impress your guests with barbeque style meals, charcoal might be the way to go as many people consider a charcoal grill the best grill for flavor.

Charcoal grills also allow for a variety of cooking techniques to be implemented. From direct grilling to indirect smoking, you’re sure to discover a style you love and want to master. This versatility provides opportunities for you to experiment with your meals and discover your personal style. To help you discover ways other people use their grills, look into charcoal grill cooking techniques!

Charcoal grills are also what most people consider “traditional” grilling, adding to the fun of the event. Guests will enjoy gathering around at your next cookout to watch you flex your grill master skills and take in the rich, smoky aroma of your delicious grilling creation.

Drawbacks of Charcoal Grills

While charcoal grills are a favorite for many grill masters, they do come with some flaws. Precise charcoal grill temperature control can be challenging as the charcoal can be a bit finicky. For someone newer to grilling, this challenge can be frustrating and can lead to easily underdone or overdone foods. It can also take a while for the charcoal to reach the correct temperature, so if you struggle with patience, this type of grill might not be for you. However, you can always search for charcoal grilling tips to help you make the most of your cooking endeavors.

Gas Grill

Gas Grill Advantages

Choosing between gas and charcoal can be a tough decision. Gas grill features can be very different from their charcoal counterparts. For one, gas grills provide instant, consistent heat control. This makes them a preferred choice for those who seek convenience and precision in their cooking. While there is no best grilling method for beginners, this type of grill might make things a bit easier. Forget waiting around for the grill to get hot; with the turn of a knob, your grill will be at the exact temperature you want in no time. Gas grills are often better for people with a large family or busy schedules as they get dinner on the table quicker than their charcoal-powered counterparts.

Gas grill maintenance also tends to be easier because you do not have the charcoal aspect to deal with. This more streamlined process is nice for families who and individuals who do not want to spend a lot of time dealing with and cleaning the grill after each meal.

Drawbacks of Gas Grills

The one drawback of a gas grill is that it does not provide the smoky barbeque flavor that a charcoal grill does. Because there is no charcoal used, you do not get the “grilled” flavor you expect at a cookout. This, however, does allow the natural flavors of the food you’re cooking to shine. As long as you know how to season your food, you should still be able to create a flavorful meal.

Gas vs. Charcoal Grill Pros and Cons

When it comes to outdoor cooking options, there is not one best grill for outdoor cooking. Your decision is mainly based on your grilling flavor preferences along with your skill level and patience. While there are flavor differences in gas and charcoal grilling, one is not better than the other. They’re simply different.

Whether you’re looking for the rich, smoky flavor of charcoal or gas grill convenience and precision, Godby Hearth and Home has a wide variety of grills and grill accessories to match your tastes and lifestyle. Stop by our showroom to view our full selection of gas-powered grills and charcoal grills by Broilmaster, Fire Magic, and Primo.

Contact us today to get grilling tomorrow! We’d love to help you get set up with the perfect grill and the accessories you need to make the meals you love.